Old Fashioned Custard Pie

     Jump to Recipe

    My great grandmother was a wizard in the kitchen. I remember when I was little, I would jump off the school bus, and instead of walking to the house, I would run for great grannies because she would always have something good cooking on the stove. I can still remember the aromatic smells that would assail my senses as soon as I stepped through her door. I can feel the nostalgia wash over me as I sit here reminiscing. Great Granny Opal was a pint-sizes lady, barely four foot ten, but the love and pride she had for her family made her seem so much taller.

    One of my favorite desserts she would make was her Old Fashioned Egg Custard Pie. I would only get it two times a year; Thanksgiving and Christmas, and every year I could hardly wait. The recipe was finally passed down to me about twenty years ago when I graduated high school, and it has been my duty to carry the tradition of making the Egg Custard Pie for our holiday meals.

Now, Egg Custard Pie isn’t the prettiest pie out there, but I promise you it will more than make up for it in flavor. The first thing you need is a deep-dish pie crust. Deep dish is a must because the filling will expand when cooking, and custard pie runoff in your oven is a disaster (speaking from experience, not fun to clean).

STEP ONE:  Break three eggs into your bowl and whisk gently. 

    STEP TWO: Add sugar and mix until combined. My kids always hate this part because they say it looks gross. I have to agree with them, but the end results are worth it.

    STEP THREE: Add milk, flour, salt, and nutmeg. Beat the mixture well. The amount of nutmeg you use depends on taste. I tend to use more than a pinch, but I love the flavor.

    STEP FOUR: Pour in unbaked pie shell. Bake at 450 degrees for 10 minutes. Reduce heat to 325 degrees and bake 45 minutes or until pie is just a little jiggly. Let rest in the refrigerator until pie is firm.

    The hardest part for me when I make this pie is the waiting period. If you cut the pie too soon, then it all falls apart. Waiting two hours is the best for the perfect pie slice. In the picture below, I cheated and used a store-bought pie crust, as you can tell from the imperfect rim of the pie. Usually, I make my crust, but on this day, I was making five different pies and didn’t have the time to make the shells. In the end, I wish I had because I am not a fan of an imperfect looking pie.


Published by Green Briar Girl

For 13 years I was a single mother until I married my handsome husband. Fast forward five years and we have added 3 sons and a daughter to our household. With all those kids I rarely have time to myself but my love of writing will always find a way. I have written books in the past. My range of genres is from romance novels to nonfiction historical, poetry, and children's books. I am currently working on a mystery book that should be a very exciting read I hope! I also love genealogy and have created my own forms which I will post later for people to download to use. I hope you enjoy my writings and recipes that I plan on sharing with you here.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: